Plenty of Fish vs OkCupid (2026): Which Is Better?
Short answer
Choose OkCupid for most people: better compatibility matching, a more polished app and the most inclusive options. Choose Plenty of Fish if you want the most free features, such as messaging, search and live streaming, and better coverage outside big cities. Both let you message for free.
Last updated Thursday 5th March 2026
Smooch and the DatingPartners network have the same owner as WhichDating. Where they appear on this page, they are labelled. Who owns WhichDating
Frequently Asked Questions
Which has more fake profiles?
POF has more documented fake profile issues due to its open-access model. OkCupid has better moderation. For zero fake profiles, Smooch with compulsory ID verification is the gold standard.
Which is better for relationships?
OkCupid's values-based matching is better suited for relationship-seeking users. POF is more mixed in user intentions. For the best relationship-focused app, see our Hinge review.